top of page
Thank You, Chicago -and beyond- for 54 wonderful years.
Thank You, Bucktown, for 25 amazing ones.
Small Thin Crust
Cheese Pizza
$11.50
Limit 1 per order.
Addtl toppings extra.
WEDNESDAY
Large Deep
Dish Pizza
`$5 Off
Limit 1 per order.
Addtl toppings extra.
THURSDAY
Medium Deep
Dish Pizza
$4 Off
Limit 1 per order.
Addtl toppings extra.
Par baked pizzas for the fridge or freezer will need to be ordered 48 hours in advance
Salads & Stuffs
My Pi Mozzarella Garlic Bread
Baked with creamy whipped butter, fresh garlic, and
stuffed with mozzarella cheese.
$7.95
Vegetarian
Spicy Garlic Bread
Our open-faced cheesy garlic bread with a spice to it!
$4.50
Vegetarian
Vegan My Pi Mozzarella Garlic Bread
Baked with creamy whipped butter, fresh garlic, and
stuffed with mozzarella cheese.
$9.50
Vegan
Dinner Salad
Combination of seasonal fresh greens topped with carrots, cucumbers, tomatoes, croutons, and your choice of dressing.
Regular/Large...$7.95/10.95
$7.95
Vegetarian
Sizes
Regular$6.50
Large$9.50
Add Chicken Breast$3.95
Caesar Salad
Fresh greens with croutons and a traditional homemade Caesar dressing.
$10.50
New Option
Add Chicken Breast$3.95
Mandarin Orange Salad
Fresh greens, Mandarin oranges, mushrooms, tomatoes, red onions, blue cheese & walnuts, served with our homemade Mandarin orange vinaigrette.
$12.95
Vegetarian
Vegan Mandarin Orange Salad
Fresh greens, Mandarin oranges, mushrooms, tomatoes, red onions, & walnuts, served with our homemade Mandarin orange vinaigrette.
Regular/Large...$7.95/11.95
$7.95
Vegetarian
Cobb Salad
Tomatoes, chicken breast, eggs, blue cheese, & bacon on bed of fresh greens with your choice of dressing.
$13.95
Chef’s Salad
Roasted turkey, Kretschmar’s hickory smoked ham, cheddar cheese, cucumbers, tomatoes & hard-boiled eggs on a bed of lettuce with your choice of dressing.
$13.95
Dressings
French, 1000 Island, Ranch, Creamy Garlic, Blue Cheese, Mandarin Orange Vinaigrette, Italian, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Lite Ranch.Extra Dressing
$0.75
Ceasar Dressing
$0.95
Pizza
Cheese Deep Dish - Unique pizza in the pan ™
Small 9" (Serves 2)
$17.95
Medium 12" (Serves 2-3)
$23.50
Large 14"(Serves 4)
$28.25
Any Additional Ingredient
Small (Serves 1-2)
$2.50
Medium (Serves 2-3)
$3
Large (Serves 4-5)
$3.50
Cheese Thin Crust – Cracker Thin
12" (Serves 1-2)
$16.50
14" (Serves 2-3)
$18.95
16" (Serves 4-5)
$22.50
Personal Size
$6.50
Any additional ingredient
12" (Serves 1-2)
$2.50
14" (Serves 2-3)
$3
16" (Serves 4-5)
$3.50
Personal Size
$1.59
Additional Ingredients:
Sausage, Pepperoni, Canadian Bacon, Hamburger, Cheeseburger* (Cheddar & Hamburger), Chicken Breast*, Ham, Roast Beef, Anchovy, Mushroom, Onion, Green Peppers, Giardiniera, Jalepenos, Garlic, Black Olive, Green Olive, Artichokes*, Fresh Spinach, Fresh Tomato, Pineapple, Extra cheese. (1/2 Ingredient Charged as 75% of additional ingredient price) *Charged as a premium ingredientPersonal Thin Crust Pizza
Chicago Tavern Style thin crust in a 9" size, perfect for 1 person. Add most additional toppings for $1.59/each.
Make it a vegan pizza for an additional charge
$6.50
Specialty Pizza
My Pi Special
Italian Sausage or Pepperoni or Spinach with mushrooms, onions, & green peppers.9" (Deep)
$25.75
12" (Deep)
$33.95
14" (Deep)
$40.95
12" (Thin)
$24.95
14" (Thin)
$29.95
16" (Thin)
$34.95
New Option
New choice
Hawaiian Pizza
A classic combination! Hickory smoked ham and pineapple with My Pi’s signature tomato sauce, mozzarella, & grated Romano cheese.9" (Deep)
$22.95
12" (Deep)
$29.50
14" (Deep)
$35.25
12" (Thin)
$21.50
14" (Thin)
$24.95
16" (Thin)
$29.50
Chicken Pesto Pizza
Slow-roasted all-natural chicken breast chunks, fresh baby spinach, My Pi’s signature tomato sauce, mozzarella, grated Romano, & fresh, homemade basil pesto drizzled on top.9" (Deep)
$23.95
12" (Deep)
$30.95
14" (Deep)
$36.95
12" (Thin)
$22.95
14" (Thin)
$26.95
16" (Thin)
$30.95
Stuffed Spinach Souffle
Our lighter version of fresh chopped baby spinach & mozzarella filling with a touch of onion & basil between two crusts.Small 9" (Serves 2-3)
$24.95
Medium 12" (Serves 4-5)
$31.95
Large 14" (Serves 5-6)
$37.95
White Pizza
Crispy thin crust with a basil-pesto instead of tomato sauce.Four-Cheese
Mozzarella, provolone, bleu cheese, & Romano with a basil-pesto sauce brushed over our crispy thin crust.12''
$18.50
14''
$21.75
16''
$25.50
Modern Art Pizza
Artichokes, fresh tomato, garlic & mozzarella with our basil-pesto sauce brushed over our crispy thin crust.12"
$23.95
14''
$28.50
16''
$33.75
Sun-dried Tomato
Sun-dried tomatoes, mozzarella, provolone, & Romano cheese with our basil-pesto sauce brushed over our crispy thin crust.12''
$20.50
14''
$23.75
16''
$27.50
Vegan Pizza
Vegan version of our Famous Deep Dish Pizza or Cracker Thin CrustVegan Deep Dish - Unique pizza in the pan ™
Made with Daiya vegan mozzarella, Go Veggie Parmesan, My Pi's classic crust, and tomato sauce with Dad's secret spices & herbsSmall (9") feeds 2 people
$19.95
Medium (12") feeds 3 people
$25.50
Large (14") feeds 4 people
$30.25
Vegan
Vegan Thin Crust
Chicago Tavern Style thin crust with Daiya vegan Mozzarella, Go Veggie Parmesan and My Pi's tomato sauce with Dad's secret spices & herbsSmall (12") feeds 1-2 people
$18.50
Medium (14") feeds 2-3 people
$20.95
Large (16") feeds 3-4 people
$24.50
Vegan
Vegan Deep Dish My Pie Special with Sausage
Upton's Vegan Italian Sausage with fresh mushrooms, onions, & green peppers.Small (9") feeds 2 people
$28.75
Medium (12") feeds 3 people
$36.95
Large (14") feeds 4 people
$43.95
Vegan
Vegan Deep Dish My Pie Special with Spinach
Fresh baby Spinach with fresh mushrooms, onions, & green peppers.Small (9") feeds 2 people
$27.75
Medium (12") feeds 3 people
$35.95
Large (14") feeds 4 people
$42.95
Vegan
Vegan Thin Crust My Pi Special with Sausage
Tavern style, cracker thin crust with Upton's vegan Italian sausage, fresh mushrooms, onions & green peppers.Small (12") feeds 1-2 people
$27.95
Medium (14") feeds 2-3 people
$32.95
Large (16") feeds 3-4 people
$37.95
Vegan
Vegan Thin Crust My Pi Special with Spinach
Tavern style, cracker thin crust with baby spinach, fresh mushrooms, onions & green peppers.Small (12") feeds 1-2 people
$26.95
Medium (14") feeds 2-3 people
$31.95
Large (16") feeds 3-4 people
$36.95
Vegan
Personal Thin Crust Vegan Pizza
Chicago Tavern Style thin crust in a 9" size, perfect for 1 person. Add most additional toppings for $1.59/each. Additional Upton's Vegan Sausage $2.39
$7.50
Vegan
Soup of the Day
We serve 1 soup du jour daily. We make the next soup on the list when the previous soup runs out. These soups are served in the following order: Chicken Noodle, Chicken Tortellini, Portabella Posole, New England Clam Chowder, French Onion, Baked Potato, Chili, Cream of Mushroom, Minestrone, Broccoli, and Corn Chowder.Shrimp & Sweet Potato Chowder! Served every Friday
An original! classic shrimp chowder with real chunks of shrimp in a creamy broth with sweet potatoes & cayenne pepper to give it a sweet spiciness, finished with a touch of bacon & sherry. Served every Friday! 1/2 Pint
$5.75
Pint
$8.50
Quart
$14.95
Chicken Noodle
Made from a homemade chicken stock.1/2 pint
$4.95
Pint
$7.75
Quart
$13.95
Chicken Tortellini
Chicken stock based soup with tortellini, Italian sausage, spinach & finished with a touch of cream1/2 Pint
$4.95
Pint
$7.75
Quart
$13.95
Portabella Posole
Another Li’l Guys original! A vegetable chili broth with Portabella mushrooms, hominy, corn, & black beans. Such spicy flavor & healthy for you, too!1/2 Pint
$4.95
Pint
$7.75
Quart
$13.95
Vegan
New England Clam Chowder
The creamy one!1/2 Pint
$4.95
Pint
$7.75
Quart
$13.95
French Onion
Onions are slowly simmered for hours!1/2 Pint
$4.95
Pint
$7.75
Quart
$13.95
Baked Potato Soup
Baking the potatoes brings out their rich flavor. Indulge yourself, we’ll top it!1.2 Pint
$4.95
Pint
$7.75
Quart
$13.95
Add Cheddar Cheese
$1.25
Add Bacon
$0.75
Chili
Beefy version with beans.1/2 Pint
$5.75
Pint
$8.50
Quart
$14.95
Cream Of Mushroom
A 40 year old family recipe.1/2 Pint
$4.95
Pint
$7.75
Quart
$13.95
Vegetarian
Minestrone
Classic Italian Soup.1/2 Pint
$4.95
Pint
$7.75
Quart
$13.95
Cream of Broccoli
Fresh broccoli in a french veloute.1/2 Pint
$4.95
Pint
$7.75
Quart
$13.95
Corn Chowder
A light chowder with sparkling corn flavor.1/2 Pint
$4.95
Pint
$7.75
Quart
$13.95
Desserts
Always Homemade!Chocolate Chip Cookies
Made with Hershey's chocolate chips
$2.25
Vegetarian
Brownies
Fudgy Brownies made with Hershey's Chocolate
$3.95
Vegetarian
Cheesecake
30 year old family recipe
$4.95
Vegetarian
Mia's Vegan White Chocolate Chip Cookie
Homemade with flaxseed and Enjoy Life's vegan white chocolate chips.
$2.75
Vegan
Real Fruit Smoothies
Our smoothies are fat-free and all-natural, made from 100 % real fruit and juice, no mixes or fillers. Try one, you’ll love it. *Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice.01 Strawberry, Banana, & Juice*
Small
$6.95
Large
$8.50
02 Strawberry, Blueberry, & Juice*
Small
$7.45
Large
$9.25
03 Strawberry, Raspberry, & Juice*
Small
$7.70
Large
$10
04 Blueberry, Banana & Juice*
Small
$7.45
Large
$9.25
05 Peach, Banana, & Juice*
Small
$6.95
Large
$8.50
06 Mango, Banana, & Juice*
Small
$6.95
Large
$8.50
07 Make your own! Pick 2 fruits & a Juice
Pick from strawberry, banana, peach, mango, blueberry & raspberry
Blueberries +$.50 (small), +$.75 (Large)
Raspberries +.75 (small), +$1.50 (Large)Small
$6.95
Large
$8.50
Additional Ingredients
+ Smoothie, Raspberries: Small$0.75
+ Smoothie Blueberries: Small$0.50
+ Smoothies Raspberries: Large$1.50
Add-Ons
Protein Shot
$0.75
Ice Cream
$1
Frozen Yogurt
$1
Beverages
Bottled Water
1/2 Liter
$1.75
Coke, Diet Coke Or Sprite
Can or 2 Liters12 oz Can
$1.75
2 Liter Bottle
$4.95
Fountain Drinks
Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Coke Zero, Lemonade, Red Cream Soda
$2.50
San Pellegrino soda can
Blood Orange or Lemon
$2.75
IBC’s 12oz bottles of:
Root Beer or Cream Soda
$2.75
Apple Juice (16oz Bottle)
$2.50
bottom of page